{"title":"Blacklight Inspection","page_title":"Off the convex path","uri_ins":"http://www.offconvex.org/","uri_dest":"https://www.offconvex.org/","uri_redirects":["http://www.offconvex.org/"],"secure_connection":{},"host":"www.offconvex.org","config":{"emulateDevice":{"name":"iPhone 14 Pro Max","userAgent":"Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; CPU iPhone OS 16_6 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/605.1.15 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/16.6 Mobile/15E148 Safari/604.1","viewport":{"width":430,"height":739,"deviceScaleFactor":3,"isMobile":true,"hasTouch":true,"isLandscape":false}},"cleareCache":true,"captureHar":true,"captureLinks":false,"enableAdBlock":false,"saveBrowserProfile":false,"numPages":2,"defaultTimeout":35000,"defaultWaitUntil":"networkidle2","headless":true,"headers":{},"extraChromiumArgs":["--disable-features=TrackingProtection3pcd","--website-analysis-scan=ce4c01e5-dc66-44f3-8fc1-ab181fa0825a"],"extraPuppeteerOptions":{}},"browser":{"name":"Chromium","version":"Chrome/127.0.6533.88","user_agent":"Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) HeadlessChrome/127.0.0.0 Safari/537.36","platform":{"name":"Linux","version":"6.12.107+deb13-amd64"}},"script":{"host":"82cd976bb63a","version":{"npm":"3.11.0","commit":"dev"},"node_version":"v24.21.0"},"start_time":"2026-09-13T22:19:55.347Z","end_time":"2026-09-13T22:20:14.286Z","browsing_history":["https://www.offconvex.org/","https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/"],"hosts":{"requests":{"first_party":["www.offconvex.org"],"third_party":["fonts.googleapis.com","maxcdn.bootstrapcdn.com","cdn.mathjax.org","www.googletagmanager.com","cdnjs.cloudflare.com","www.google-analytics.com","fonts.gstatic.com","region1.google-analytics.com","openai.com","offconvex.disqus.com","disqus.com","c.disquscdn.com","cdn.viglink.com","referrer.disqus.com","links.services.disqus.com","api.viglink.com"]}},"reports":{"behaviour_event_listeners":{"MOUSE":{"https://c.disquscdn.com/next/embed/alfie_v4.63f1ab6d6b9d5807dc0c94ef3fe0b851.js":["click","mousedown"],"https://c.disquscdn.com/embedv2/latest/embedv2.js":["scroll"],"https://c.disquscdn.com/next/embed/common.bundle.712217b7f5a618b8bc684129c2acd47a.js":["click"],"https://c.disquscdn.com/next/embed/lounge.bundle.56587242107f7f290d4779d6435b5483.js":["click","scroll","mousemove"],"https://c.disquscdn.com/next/recommendations/common.bundle.43d7b81d7be743ddbbff9eeae86f2a4b.js":["click"],"https://c.disquscdn.com/next/recommendations/recommendations.bundle.e10dd10b7f8cbf10e87b9f893f636092.js":["click","scroll","mousemove"],"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&cx=c&gtm=4e6992":["click"],"https://offconvex.disqus.com/recommendations.js":["click","scroll","mousemove"],"https://offconvex.disqus.com/embed.js":["click","scroll","mousemove"],"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&cx=c&gtm=4e6992h1":["click"]},"KEYBOARD":{"https://c.disquscdn.com/next/embed/common.bundle.712217b7f5a618b8bc684129c2acd47a.js":["keypress"],"https://c.disquscdn.com/next/recommendations/common.bundle.43d7b81d7be743ddbbff9eeae86f2a4b.js":["keypress"]}},"canvas_fingerprinters":{"data_url":{},"fingerprinters":[],"styles":{},"texts":{}},"canvas_font_fingerprinters":{"canvas_font":{},"text_measure":{}},"cookies":[{"name":"_gid","value":"GA1.2.1309560844.1789338007","domain":"offconvex.org","path":"/","expires":"2026-09-14T22:20:06.000Z","size":31,"httpOnly":false,"secure":false,"session":false,"priority":"Medium","sameParty":false,"sourceScheme":"Secure","sourcePort":443,"type":"js","third_party":false},{"name":"_gat","value":"1","domain":"offconvex.org","path":"/","expires":"2026-09-13T22:21:06.000Z","size":5,"httpOnly":false,"secure":false,"session":false,"priority":"Medium","sameParty":false,"sourceScheme":"Secure","sourcePort":443,"type":"js","third_party":false},{"name":"_gat_gtag_UA_129080604_1","value":"1","domain":"offconvex.org","path":"/","expires":"2026-09-13T22:21:06.000Z","size":25,"httpOnly":false,"secure":false,"session":false,"priority":"Medium","sameParty":false,"sourceScheme":"Secure","sourcePort":443,"type":"js","third_party":false},{"name":"_ga_WQB2V93JP2","value":"GS2.2.s1789338006$o1$g0$t1789338006$j60$l0$h0","domain":"offconvex.org","path":"/","expires":"2027-10-18T22:20:06.812Z","size":59,"httpOnly":false,"secure":false,"session":false,"priority":"Medium","sameParty":false,"sourceScheme":"Secure","sourcePort":443,"type":"js","third_party":false},{"name":"_ga_J26H5SDMR7","value":"GS2.1.s1789337998$o1$g1$t1789338006$j52$l0$h0","domain":"offconvex.org","path":"/","expires":"2027-10-18T22:20:06.884Z","size":59,"httpOnly":false,"secure":false,"session":false,"priority":"Medium","sameParty":false,"sourceScheme":"Secure","sourcePort":443,"type":"js","third_party":false},{"name":"_ga","value":"GA1.1.51898211.1789338007","domain":"offconvex.org","path":"/","expires":"2027-10-18T22:20:06.885Z","size":28,"httpOnly":false,"secure":false,"session":false,"priority":"Medium","sameParty":false,"sourceScheme":"Secure","sourcePort":443,"type":"js","third_party":false}],"fb_pixel_events":[],"tiktok_pixel_events":[],"twitter_pixel_events":[],"google_analytics_events":[],"key_logging":{},"session_recorders":{},"third_party_trackers":[{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_eu":"AAAIAAQ","_p":1789338006504,"_s":1,"are":1,"cid":51898211.1789338,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","dma":1,"dma_cps":"a","dt":"How to allow deep learning on your data without revealing the data – Off the convex path","en":"page_view","frm":0,"gcd":"13l3l3l2l1l1","gtm":"45je6992v896793179za20g","ngs":1,"npa":1,"pscdl":"","rcb":1,"sct":1,"seg":1,"sid":1789337998,"sr":"430x739","tag_exp":"115938466~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120469145~120469153~120474864","tfd":5570,"tid":"G-J26H5SDMR7","uaa":"","uab":"","uafvl":"","uam":"","uamb":0,"uap":"","uapv":"","uaw":0,"ul":"en-us","v":2}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-J26H5SDMR7&gtm=45je6992v896793179za20g&_p=1789338006504&gcd=13l3l3l2l1l1&npa=1&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=AAAIAAQ&are=1&cid=51898211.1789338007&frm=0&ngs=1&pscdl=&rcb=1&sr=430x739&uaa=&uab=&uafvl=&uam=&uamb=0&uap=&uapv=&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=1&tag_exp=115938466~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120469145~120469153~120474864&sid=1789337998&sct=1&seg=1&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2020%2F11%2F11%2Finstahide%2F&dt=How%20to%20allow%20deep%20learning%20on%20your%20data%20without%20revealing%20the%20data%20%E2%80%93%20Off%20the%20convex%20path&en=page_view&tfd=5570"},{"data":{"body":"format=jsonp&jsonp=vglnk_17893380081747&key=cfdfcf52dffd0a702a61bad27507376d&subId=3895736&loc=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2020%2F11%2F11%2Finstahide%2F&v=2","filter":"||disqus.com/api/ping","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://links.services.disqus.com/api/ping"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||referrer.disqus.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"abe":0,"dnt":0,"embed_hidden":0,"event":"init_embed","experiment":"videofloorexp_hidden","forum":"offconvex","forum_id":3895736,"imp":"8ltv8tand6t54","load_time":542,"max_enabled":false,"promoted_enabled":false,"referrer":"https://www.offconvex.org/","service":"dynamic","theme":"next","thread":8272932996,"thread_slug":"how_to_allow_deep_learning_on_your_data_without_revealing_the_data","tracking_enabled":0,"user_type":"anon","variant":"active"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://disqus.com/embed/comments/?base=default&f=offconvex&t_i=%2F2020%2F11%2F11%2Finstahide&t_u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2020%2F11%2F11%2Finstahide%2F&t_e=How%20to%20allow%20deep%20learning%20on%20your%20data%20without%20revealing%20the%20data&t_d=How%20to%20allow%20deep%20learning%20on%20your%20data%20without%20revealing%20the%20data&t_t=How%20to%20allow%20deep%20learning%20on%20your%20data%20without%20revealing%20the%20data&s_o=default#version=341dee12be34cd058eb373ee8584d1b1","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://referrer.disqus.com/juggler/event.gif?abe=0&embed_hidden=0&load_time=542&event=init_embed&thread=8272932996&forum=offconvex&forum_id=3895736&imp=8ltv8tand6t54&thread_slug=how_to_allow_deep_learning_on_your_data_without_revealing_the_data&user_type=anon&theme=next&dnt=0&tracking_enabled=0&experiment=videofloorexp_hidden&variant=active&service=dynamic&promoted_enabled=false&max_enabled=false&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||referrer.disqus.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"event":"cmp.gpp.absent"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://referrer.disqus.com/juggler/stat.gif?event=cmp.gpp.absent"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"/pixel.gif?","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"ch":2,"rn":5.992008672619037}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://cdn.viglink.com/images/pixel.gif?ch=2&rn=5.992008672619037"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"/pixel.gif?","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"ch":1,"rn":5.992008672619037}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://cdn.viglink.com/images/pixel.gif?ch=1&rn=5.992008672619037"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_ee":1,"_eu":"ABAI","_fv":1,"_p":1789338006504,"_s":1,"_ss":1,"are":1,"cid":51898211.1789338,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","dma":1,"dma_cps":"a","dt":"How to allow deep learning on your data without revealing the data – Off the convex path","en":"page_view","frm":0,"gcd":"13l3l3l2l2l1","gtm":"45je6992v9110587412za20g","ngs":1,"npa":0,"pscdl":"","rcb":6,"sct":1,"seg":0,"sid":1789338006,"sr":"430x739","tag_exp":"115938466~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120469145~120469153~120912438","tfd":496,"tid":"G-WQB2V93JP2","uaa":"","uab":"","uafvl":"","uam":"","uamb":0,"uap":"","uapv":"","uaw":0,"ul":"en-us","v":2}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-WQB2V93JP2&gtm=45je6992v9110587412za20g&_p=1789338006504&gcd=13l3l3l2l2l1&npa=0&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=ABAI&are=1&cid=51898211.1789338007&frm=0&ngs=1&pscdl=&rcb=6&sr=430x739&uaa=&uab=&uafvl=&uam=&uamb=0&uap=&uapv=&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=1&tag_exp=115938466~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120469145~120469153~120912438&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2020%2F11%2F11%2Finstahide%2F&dt=How%20to%20allow%20deep%20learning%20on%20your%20data%20without%20revealing%20the%20data%20%E2%80%93%20Off%20the%20convex%20path&sid=1789338006&sct=1&seg=0&en=page_view&_fv=1&_ss=1&_ee=1&tfd=496"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"cx":"c","gtm":null,"id":"G-J26H5SDMR7"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&cx=c&gtm=4e6992"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_slc":1,"cx":"c","id":"G-WQB2V93JP2"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-WQB2V93JP2&cx=c&_slc=1"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_gid":1309560844.1789339,"_r":1,"_s":1,"_slc":1,"_u":"IEBAAEABAAAAACAAI~","_v":"j102","a":817002235,"cid":51898211.1789338,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","dt":"How to allow deep learning on your data without revealing the data – Off the convex path","gjid":1512176020,"jid":549425578,"sr":"430x739","t":"pageview","tid":"UA-70478681-1","ul":"en-us","v":1,"vp":"430x739","z":808045072}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.google-analytics.com/j/collect?v=1&_v=j102&a=817002235&t=pageview&_s=1&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2020%2F11%2F11%2Finstahide%2F&ul=en-us&dt=How%20to%20allow%20deep%20learning%20on%20your%20data%20without%20revealing%20the%20data%20%E2%80%93%20Off%20the%20convex%20path&sr=430x739&vp=430x739&_u=IEBAAEABAAAAACAAI~&jid=549425578&gjid=1512176020&cid=51898211.1789338007&tid=UA-70478681-1&_gid=1309560844.1789338007&_r=1&_slc=1&z=808045072"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"id":"UA-129080604-1"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2020/11/11/instahide/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=UA-129080604-1"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"dl":"www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","exp":"115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439","fin":1,"gtm":"45je6992v896793179za20gxf1","id":"G-J26H5SDMR7","img":1,"mde":"G-J26H5SDMR7;16_1;61_1","pid":1575282235,"seq":2,"t":"t","tdp":"G-J26H5SDMR7;96793179;1;1;0","v":3,"z":0}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/td?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&v=3&t=t&pid=1575282235&gtm=45je6992v896793179za20gxf1&seq=2&exp=115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439&dl=www.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&tdp=G-J26H5SDMR7;96793179;1;1;0&mde=G-J26H5SDMR7;16_1;61_1&fin=1&z=0&img=1"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_et":5426,"_eu":"AAAI","_p":1789338000426,"_s":2,"are":1,"cid":111652616.1789338,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","dma":1,"dma_cps":"a","dt":"Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), Some Open Questions – Off the convex path","en":"user_engagement","frm":0,"gcd":"13l3l3l2l1l1","gtm":"45je6992v896793179za20gxf1","ngs":1,"npa":1,"pscdl":"","rcb":8,"sct":1,"seg":1,"sid":1789337998,"sr":"430x739","tag_exp":"115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439","tfd":6240,"tid":"G-J26H5SDMR7","uaa":"","uab":"","uafvl":"","uam":"","uamb":0,"uap":"","uapv":"","uaw":0,"ul":"en-us","v":2}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-J26H5SDMR7&gtm=45je6992v896793179za20gxf1&_p=1789338000426&gcd=13l3l3l2l1l1&npa=1&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=AAAI&are=1&cid=111652616.1789338001&frm=0&ngs=1&pscdl=&rcb=8&sr=430x739&uaa=&uab=&uafvl=&uam=&uamb=0&uap=&uapv=&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=2&tag_exp=115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439&sid=1789337998&sct=1&seg=1&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&dt=Generative%20Adversarial%20Networks%20(GANs)%2C%20Some%20Open%20Questions%20%E2%80%93%20Off%20the%20convex%20path&en=user_engagement&_et=5426&tfd=6240"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"cx":"c","dl":"www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","exp":"115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439","fin":1,"gtm":"45je6992v896793179za20gxf1","id":"G-J26H5SDMR7","is_td":1,"mde":"G-J26H5SDMR7;16_1;61_1","pid":1575282235,"seq":2,"t":"t","tdp":"G-J26H5SDMR7;96793179;1;1;0","v":3,"z":0}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&cx=c&gtm=4e6992&is_td=1&v=3&t=t&pid=1575282235&gtm=45je6992v896793179za20gxf1&seq=2&exp=115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439&dl=www.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&tdp=G-J26H5SDMR7;96793179;1;1;0&mde=G-J26H5SDMR7;16_1;61_1&fin=1&z=0"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"dl":"www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","exp":"115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439","fin":1,"gtm":"45je6992v896793179za20gxf1","id":"G-J26H5SDMR7","mde":"G-J26H5SDMR7;16_1;61_1","pid":1575282235,"seq":2,"t":"t","tdp":"G-J26H5SDMR7;96793179;1;1;0","v":3,"z":0}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/td?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&v=3&t=t&pid=1575282235&gtm=45je6992v896793179za20gxf1&seq=2&exp=115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439&dl=www.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&tdp=G-J26H5SDMR7;96793179;1;1;0&mde=G-J26H5SDMR7;16_1;61_1&fin=1&z=0"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_eu":"AAAIAAQ","_p":1789338000426,"_s":1,"are":1,"cid":111652616.1789338,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","dma":1,"dma_cps":"a","dt":"Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), Some Open Questions – Off the convex path","en":"page_view","frm":0,"gcd":"13l3l3l2l1l1","gtm":"45je6992v896793179za20gxf1","ngs":1,"npa":1,"pscdl":"","rcb":8,"sct":1,"seg":1,"sid":1789337998,"sr":"430x739","tag_exp":"115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439","tfd":5805,"tid":"G-J26H5SDMR7","uaa":"","uab":"","uafvl":"","uam":"","uamb":0,"uap":"","uapv":"","uaw":0,"ul":"en-us","v":2}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-J26H5SDMR7&gtm=45je6992v896793179za20gxf1&_p=1789338000426&gcd=13l3l3l2l1l1&npa=1&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=AAAIAAQ&are=1&cid=111652616.1789338001&frm=0&ngs=1&pscdl=&rcb=8&sr=430x739&uaa=&uab=&uafvl=&uam=&uamb=0&uap=&uapv=&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=1&tag_exp=115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439&sid=1789337998&sct=1&seg=1&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&dt=Generative%20Adversarial%20Networks%20(GANs)%2C%20Some%20Open%20Questions%20%E2%80%93%20Off%20the%20convex%20path&en=page_view&tfd=5805"},{"data":{"body":"format=jsonp&jsonp=vglnk_17893380024007&key=cfdfcf52dffd0a702a61bad27507376d&subId=3895736&loc=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&v=2","filter":"||disqus.com/api/ping","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://links.services.disqus.com/api/ping"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||referrer.disqus.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"abe":0,"dnt":0,"embed_hidden":0,"event":"init_embed","experiment":"videofloorexp_hidden","forum":"offconvex","forum_id":3895736,"imp":"8ltv2qu2u1dpja","load_time":410,"max_enabled":false,"promoted_enabled":false,"referrer":"https://www.offconvex.org/","service":"dynamic","theme":"next","thread":5635358675,"thread_slug":"generative_adversarial_networks_gans_some_open_questions","tracking_enabled":0,"user_type":"anon","variant":"active"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://disqus.com/embed/comments/?base=default&f=offconvex&t_i=%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs&t_u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&t_e=Generative%20Adversarial%20Networks%20(GANs)%2C%20Some%20Open%20Questions&t_d=Generative%20Adversarial%20Networks%20(GANs)%2C%20Some%20Open%20Questions&t_t=Generative%20Adversarial%20Networks%20(GANs)%2C%20Some%20Open%20Questions&s_o=default#version=341dee12be34cd058eb373ee8584d1b1","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://referrer.disqus.com/juggler/event.gif?abe=0&embed_hidden=0&load_time=410&event=init_embed&thread=5635358675&forum=offconvex&forum_id=3895736&imp=8ltv2qu2u1dpja&thread_slug=generative_adversarial_networks_gans_some_open_questions&user_type=anon&theme=next&dnt=0&tracking_enabled=0&experiment=videofloorexp_hidden&variant=active&service=dynamic&promoted_enabled=false&max_enabled=false&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||referrer.disqus.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"event":"cmp.gpp.absent"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://referrer.disqus.com/juggler/stat.gif?event=cmp.gpp.absent"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"/pixel.gif?","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"ch":2,"rn":0.21585360159397915}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://cdn.viglink.com/images/pixel.gif?ch=2&rn=0.21585360159397915"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"/pixel.gif?","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"ch":1,"rn":0.21585360159397915}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://cdn.viglink.com/images/pixel.gif?ch=1&rn=0.21585360159397915"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"bt":0,"ct":3,"dl":"www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","exp":"115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439","frm":0,"gtm":"45je6992v896793179za20gxf1","hlo":10,"id":"G-J26H5SDMR7","lst":3,"pcid":"_UA-129080604-1","pid":1575282235,"seq":1,"slo":1,"t":"t","tdp":"G-J26H5SDMR7;96793179;1;1;0","v":3,"z":0}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/td?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&v=3&t=t&pid=1575282235&gtm=45je6992v896793179za20gxf1&seq=1&exp=115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120420415~120469145~120469153~120912439&dl=www.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&tdp=G-J26H5SDMR7;96793179;1;1;0&frm=0&slo=1&hlo=10&lst=3&pcid=_UA-129080604-1&bt=0&ct=3&z=0"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_ee":1,"_eu":"ABAI","_fv":1,"_p":1789338000426,"_s":1,"_ss":1,"are":1,"cid":111652616.1789338,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","dma":1,"dma_cps":"a","dt":"Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), Some Open Questions – Off the convex path","en":"page_view","frm":0,"gcd":"13l3l3l2l2l1","gtm":"45je6992v9110587412za20g","ngs":1,"npa":0,"pscdl":"","rcb":4,"sct":1,"seg":0,"sid":1789338000,"sr":"430x739","tag_exp":"115616986~115938465~115938468~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120469145~120469153","tfd":578,"tid":"G-WQB2V93JP2","uaa":"","uab":"","uafvl":"","uam":"","uamb":0,"uap":"","uapv":"","uaw":0,"ul":"en-us","v":2}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-WQB2V93JP2&gtm=45je6992v9110587412za20g&_p=1789338000426&gcd=13l3l3l2l2l1&npa=0&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=ABAI&are=1&cid=111652616.1789338001&frm=0&ngs=1&pscdl=&rcb=4&sr=430x739&uaa=&uab=&uafvl=&uam=&uamb=0&uap=&uapv=&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=1&tag_exp=115616986~115938465~115938468~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120469145~120469153&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&dt=Generative%20Adversarial%20Networks%20(GANs)%2C%20Some%20Open%20Questions%20%E2%80%93%20Off%20the%20convex%20path&sid=1789338000&sct=1&seg=0&en=page_view&_fv=1&_ss=1&_ee=1&tfd=578"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"cx":"c","gtm":null,"id":"G-J26H5SDMR7"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&cx=c&gtm=4e6992"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_slc":1,"cx":"c","id":"G-WQB2V93JP2"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-WQB2V93JP2&cx=c&_slc=1"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_gid":962655336.1789339,"_r":1,"_s":1,"_slc":1,"_u":"IEBAAEABAAAAACAAI~","_v":"j102","a":1716369330,"cid":111652616.1789338,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","dt":"Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), Some Open Questions – Off the convex path","gjid":1770283731,"jid":1715410798,"sr":"430x739","t":"pageview","tid":"UA-70478681-1","ul":"en-us","v":1,"vp":"430x739","z":1681124513}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.google-analytics.com/j/collect?v=1&_v=j102&a=1716369330&t=pageview&_s=1&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F2017%2F03%2F15%2FGANs%2F&ul=en-us&dt=Generative%20Adversarial%20Networks%20(GANs)%2C%20Some%20Open%20Questions%20%E2%80%93%20Off%20the%20convex%20path&sr=430x739&vp=430x739&_u=IEBAAEABAAAAACAAI~&jid=1715410798&gjid=1770283731&cid=111652616.1789338001&tid=UA-70478681-1&_gid=962655336.1789338001&_r=1&_slc=1&z=1681124513"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"id":"UA-129080604-1"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/2017/03/15/GANs/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=UA-129080604-1"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_eu":"AAAI","_fv":1,"_p":1789337997653,"_s":1,"_ss":1,"are":1,"cid":1001122878.1789339,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/","dma":1,"dma_cps":"a","dt":"Off the convex path","en":"page_view","frm":0,"gcd":"13l3l3l2l1l1","gtm":"45je6992h1v896793179za20g","ngs":1,"npa":1,"pscdl":"","rcb":18,"sct":1,"seg":0,"sid":1789337998,"sr":"430x739","tag_exp":"115616986~115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120469145~120469153","tfd":1056,"tid":"G-J26H5SDMR7","uaa":"","uab":"","uafvl":"","uam":"","uamb":0,"uap":"","uapv":"","uaw":0,"ul":"en-us","v":2}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-J26H5SDMR7&gtm=45je6992h1v896793179za20g&_p=1789337997653&gcd=13l3l3l2l1l1&npa=1&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=AAAI&are=1&cid=1001122878.1789337998&frm=0&ngs=1&pscdl=&rcb=18&sr=430x739&uaa=&uab=&uafvl=&uam=&uamb=0&uap=&uapv=&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=1&tag_exp=115616986~115938465~115938469~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385422~120469145~120469153&sid=1789337998&sct=1&seg=0&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F&dt=Off%20the%20convex%20path&en=page_view&_fv=1&_ss=1&tfd=1056"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_ee":1,"_eu":"ABAI","_fv":1,"_p":1789337997653,"_s":1,"_ss":1,"are":1,"cid":1001122878.1789339,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/","dma":1,"dma_cps":"a","dt":"Off the convex path","en":"page_view","frm":0,"gcd":"13l3l3l2l2l1","gtm":"45je6992v9110587412za20g","ngs":1,"npa":0,"pscdl":"","rcb":13,"sct":1,"seg":0,"sid":1789337998,"sr":"430x739","tag_exp":"115616985~115938465~115938468~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385423~120469145~120469153","tfd":902,"tid":"G-WQB2V93JP2","uaa":"","uab":"","uafvl":"","uam":"","uamb":0,"uap":"","uapv":"","uaw":0,"ul":"en-us","v":2}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-WQB2V93JP2&gtm=45je6992v9110587412za20g&_p=1789337997653&gcd=13l3l3l2l2l1&npa=0&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=ABAI&are=1&cid=1001122878.1789337998&frm=0&ngs=1&pscdl=&rcb=13&sr=430x739&uaa=&uab=&uafvl=&uam=&uamb=0&uap=&uapv=&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=1&tag_exp=115616985~115938465~115938468~118897920~118897930~120213116~120385423~120469145~120469153&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F&dt=Off%20the%20convex%20path&sid=1789337998&sct=1&seg=0&en=page_view&_fv=1&_ss=1&_ee=1&tfd=902"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"cx":"c","gtm":"4e6992h1","id":"G-J26H5SDMR7"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-J26H5SDMR7&cx=c&gtm=4e6992h1"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_slc":1,"cx":"c","id":"G-WQB2V93JP2"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-WQB2V93JP2&cx=c&_slc=1"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"_gid":428335658.1789338,"_r":1,"_s":1,"_slc":1,"_u":"IEBAAEABAAAAACAAI~","_v":"j102","a":628675854,"cid":1001122878.1789339,"dl":"https://www.offconvex.org/","dt":"Off the convex path","gjid":309915482,"jid":437076560,"sr":"430x739","t":"pageview","tid":"UA-70478681-1","ul":"en-us","v":1,"vp":"430x739","z":931276822}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.google-analytics.com/j/collect?v=1&_v=j102&a=628675854&t=pageview&_s=1&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.offconvex.org%2F&ul=en-us&dt=Off%20the%20convex%20path&sr=430x739&vp=430x739&_u=IEBAAEABAAAAACAAI~&jid=437076560&gjid=309915482&cid=1001122878.1789337998&tid=UA-70478681-1&_gid=428335658.1789337998&_r=1&_slc=1&z=931276822"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||google-analytics.com^$third-party","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js"},{"data":{"body":{},"filter":"||googletagmanager.com^","listName":"easyprivacy.txt","query":{"id":"UA-129080604-1"}},"stack":[{"fileName":"https://www.offconvex.org/","source":"ThirdPartyTracker RequestHandler"}],"type":"TrackingRequest","url":"https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=UA-129080604-1"}]}}